Walking into the Palmer Museum of Art, there
were many paintings and sculptures that caught my eye, but one in particular
seemed to possess more meaning than the others.
Harlem Rose was not the most
colorful and outrageous piece of art that I observed at the museum, but in my
opinion, it was the most intriguing and moving.
In this 2005-2006 piece, African American artist Willie Cole creates what reminded me of a flower or a sunburst out of old, worn women’s shoes. One shoe is placed in the center of the piece, the toe pointing outward. All of the other shoes are placed around it in the same fashion with their toes pointing out and their rubber outsoles facing the innermost shoe. This presents the viewer with the illusion of petals on a flower. The shoes are neutral in color, most of them being black or brown, and the rubber outsoles are all a light brown or tan shade. The light color of the bottom of the shoe enables the viewer to see the scuffs and age in each individual shoe.
While Harlem Rose was created more recently, Cole was born in 1955. At that point in American history, there was
great racial division and unrest throughout the country. The Civil Rights Movement had begun to pick
up speed, as African Americans participated in bus boycotts, sit-ins, and
freedom rides in a fight for equality. Cole,
an African America born during this time period, would therefore clearly have a true
connection to the era of civil rights. According to the plaque next to the piece, Cole has
created other sculptures from consumer objects that workers would have worn or
used besides Harlem Rose. Many of his works relate to West
African culture or African American life in the Americas.
Knowing about the rhetorical situation of the piece, it is obvious that Cole was trying to make a point that African American women during the era of racial discrimination worked hard to achieve the equality that they desired. By seeing the worn-down shoes of working African American women, Cole uses pathos to appeal to the viewer’s emotions. It’s easy to visualize the struggles that the African American women of the time period suffered through by simply looking at the scuffs on the shoes. Knowing about the bus boycotts in Montgomery and Rosa Parks influence on the boycotts, I wondered if the title was a connection between the two. A powerful woman and a powerful location create an affective title to the piece with so much meaning.
Before this assignment, I was unaware
that Penn State even had it’s own arts museum, so it was a pleasant surprise to
hear that our English class would be going there on a trip. I am a big fan of art, from paintings and
sculptures to music, so being able to explore the museum was an enjoyable experience. Though the museum was not huge, there were a
lot of interesting and entertaining pieces that made me think. The trip definitely showed me a different
side of Penn State that I would have never known to explore.
Harlem Rose had caught my eye too, but it didn’t exactly “move me.” As a sculpture, I thought the idea was pretty fantastic. The style of it is something I’d easily mistake as something a bit more modern. What I want to get at is that your research behind the piece is pretty great. It adds much more depth to the piece than I even had in mind initially. Would you mind sharing your sources for this? I still need to find some background on my own choice. Nice critique, and thank you for sharing the background on the piece!
ReplyDeleteI love this piece! I remember seeing it when I went and I was so fascinated by it. I'm glad you did background research on it because I was really interested to hear the story behind it! Nice work :)
ReplyDeleteRyan, sorry that I just saw this! I actually wrote a large research paper on the Civil Rights Movement, so I already knew a sizable amount about what was happening during this time period. Also the plaque next to the piece of art provided a lot of information about the author himself and his goals in creating the piece. I didn't really have to do too much research on it! Thanks for commenting, both of you!
ReplyDeleteYou're right, this piece is so intriguing! its great that you had access to the historical context of the piece. It makes it even more interesting! LIke you, I was unaware that Penn State had its own museum. I obviously could not analyze every piece, so I enjoyed reading your analysis to learn more about one of the many great pieces at the Palmer.
ReplyDelete